LP SmartSide vs Hardie: Which Siding Is Best in 2025?
Puetz Construction | 9 Minute Read
When it comes to choosing siding for your home, LP SmartSide and James Hardie (commonly referred to as Hardie) are two standout options. Each boasts a combination of durability and aesthetic appeal, but how do you decide which one is better for your home?
This guide covers everything you need to know, including:
- What are LP SmartSide and Hardie siding?
- Key differences between LP SmartSide vs Hardie siding
- Insights on which might be the better fit for your needs
Key Takeaways:
- LP SmartSide is engineered wood, offering lightweight installation and natural wood-grain texture at a lower upfront cost.
- Hardie Board is fiber cement, known for superior fire and moisture resistance. Ideal for harsh climates or wildfire zones.
- Installation and maintenance needs differ, with LP being easier to install, and Hardie requiring more upkeep over time.
- Both provide strong aesthetics, but your choice will depend on climate, budget, and personal style preferences.
- Our detailed comparison table and expert insights below will help you choose confidently.
What Are LP SmartSide and Hardie Siding?
LP SmartSide and Hardie Siding are durable, high-quality siding options that protect homes from weather and wear. Choosing the right siding ensures long-lasting performance and enhances curb appeal. Working with trusted siding contractors can also make the selection and installation process easier, ensuring your home gets the full benefits of these materials.
LP SmartSide
- Engineered wood siding is designed for strength and resilience
- Made from wood strands coated with a resin binder
- Treated with waxes, zinc borate, and other protective elements for enhanced water resistance and durability
- Versatile with a warm, wood-like aesthetic
Hardie Siding
- Also known as HardiePlank, made of fiber cement (wood fibers, cement, and sand)
- Renowned for its toughness and non-combustible properties
- Withstands extreme weather conditions effectively
- Popular in North America for its long-lasting appearance and unmatched durability
5 Key Differences Between LP SmartSide and Hardie Siding
Understanding the differences between LP SmartSide and Hardie Siding is crucial for choosing the right material for your home. Each option offers unique benefits in durability, maintenance, and style that can impact long-term performance and costs.
1. Durability and Weather Resistance
LP SmartSide is engineered for impact resistance and treated to resist moisture, rot, and pests. While it offers excellent weather resistance, it performs best in climates with less exposure to heavy rainfall or extreme humidity. On the other hand, Hardie Siding is known for its exceptional durability. It stands out in high-moisture or wildfire-prone areas, making it an ideal choice for homes exposed to tough weather conditions year-round. Its ability to handle extreme environments has made it a favorite among homeowners looking for reliable, long-lasting siding.
2. Maintenance
LP SmartSide is a great low-maintenance siding option due to its factory-applied finish, which helps it retain its appearance over time. However, occasional cleaning and inspections can go a long way in maintaining its look and longevity. In comparison, Hardie Siding, made from fiber cement, is tougher but demands more upkeep. Routine repainting every 10 to 15 years is often necessary to keep its finish vibrant and fresh. While both options require some level of care, Hardie Siding tends to involve more intensive maintenance in the long run.
3. Installation
LP SmartSide is lighter and easier to cut, handle, and install compared to fiber cement alternatives. Its lightweight design can help reduce labor costs and project timelines, making it a practical choice for those who want an efficient installation process. On the other hand, Hardie Siding is heavier and more challenging to work with. It requires specialized cutting tools and skilled labor, which can lead to higher installation costs. Both materials can deliver excellent results, but to ensure proper performance and lasting curb appeal, it’s best to let siding professionals handle the installation.
4. Cost
When it comes to cost, LP SmartSide is generally more affordable upfront, both in terms of materials and installation. This makes it a great option for homeowners seeking cost-effectiveness without compromising on quality. Hardie Siding, in contrast, comes with a higher initial price tag. However, its long-term durability and ability to withstand harsh weather conditions often justify the investment over time. For those focusing on long-term value, Hardie Siding can be a worthwhile choice despite the higher upfront costs.
5. Aesthetic Appeal
LP SmartSide offers a wood-grain texture that is natural and timeless, making it suitable for a wide variety of home styles. Its broad range of color options allows homeowners to customize their siding to match their specific aesthetic preferences. Meanwhile, Hardie Siding stands out with its smoother texture and classic, refined appearance. It is available in an array of colors and finishes, making it a versatile choice for those looking to achieve a polished and sophisticated look for their homes. Both options provide excellent aesthetic appeal, ensuring there is a siding solution to suit every taste.
LP SmartSide vs Hardie: Quick Comparison Table
| Feature | LP SmartSide | Hardie Siding (Fiber Cement) |
|---|---|---|
| Durability | Great for moderate climates; impact-resistant and moisture-treated | Extremely durable; ideal for humid, wet, or wildfire-prone areas |
| Maintenance | Low-maintenance; factory finish lasts long | Requires repainting every 10–15 years |
| Installation | Lightweight; easier and faster to install | Heavier; needs specialized tools and labor |
| Cost | Lower upfront material and labor cost | Higher upfront cost; better long-term value |
| Appearance | Textured wood-grain look; customizable colors | Smooth, refined look; wide color options with ColorPlus® |
Which Siding is Best for You?
Choosing between LP SmartSide and Hardie Siding comes down to your specific needs, priorities, and the environment where your home is located. Both options have their strengths, but understanding what they offer can help you make the right decision. Homeowners deciding between a fresh installation for new construction and a full siding replacement on an older home will also find that the right choice can vary depending on budget, condition of the structure, and long-term goals.
Why Choose LP SmartSide?
LP SmartSide siding is a standout choice for homeowners who prioritize efficiency, affordability, and aesthetics. It checks all the boxes for those seeking a reliable and stylish exterior siding option for their homes. Here’s why LP SmartSide is such a smart choice:
- Easy to Install: With its lightweight design, LP SmartSide siding is easier and quicker to install compared to heavier alternatives like fiber cement siding. This reduces installation time, labor costs, and overall project expenses, making it a cost-effective option.
- Budget-Friendly: If you’re looking for high-quality siding at a reasonable price, LP SmartSide delivers. It offers an affordable alternative to premium options like James Hardie siding without compromising on durability or appearance.
- Warm and Versatile Appearance: LP SmartSide siding boasts a natural wood-like texture that adds a cozy, welcoming feel to your home. It comes in a variety of styles, colors, and finishes, allowing you to customize the look and match it to your personal taste or architectural design.
- Ideal for Moderate Climates: This siding is specifically designed to perform well in areas with moderate humidity and weather conditions. It’s a reliable and practical choice if you live in a region without extreme weather fluctuations.
Why Choose Hardie Siding?
Hardie Siding, also known as James Hardie Siding, is the gold standard for durability, safety, and long-term value. Made from high-performance fiber cement siding, it’s an ideal solution for homeowners who want to protect their home while enhancing its curb appeal. Here’s what makes Hardie Siding a top choice:
- Unmatched Durability: James Hardie fiber cement siding is engineered to withstand even the harshest weather conditions. Whether it’s strong winds, heavy rain, freezing temperatures, or scorching heat, this siding will hold up over time, ensuring your home stays protected.
- Fire Resistance: One of the standout features of Hardie Siding is its non-combustible, fire-resistant material. If you live in a wildfire-prone area, this added layer of protection can be a significant advantage.
- Moisture and Rot Resistance: Designed to handle heavy rainfall and high humidity, Hardie Siding resists moisture damage, including rotting, swelling, and warping. This makes it an excellent choice for homes in wetter climates.
- Long-Term Value: While James Hardie fiber cement siding may have a higher upfront cost, it offers tremendous long-term value. Its durability reduces the need for repairs and maintenance, making it a cost-effective investment for your home over time.
- Proven Reputation: Hardie Siding has a solid track record of delivering exceptional performance and reliability. Trusted by millions of homeowners nationwide, it has become a household name in the world of exterior siding.
Trust Puetz Construction for Your Siding Needs
Choosing between LP SmartSide and Hardie siding comes down to your specific needs and preferences, but one thing is certain. Puetz Construction is the team ideal for siding installations you can trust to bring your vision to life.
With our licensed and insured crew, premium materials, and years of proven expertise, we’re committed to delivering siding solutions that enhance both the beauty and durability of your home. Ready to get started? Contact Puetz Construction today for a consultation and let us help you transform your home with confidence!
FAQ’s
What are the disadvantages of LP SmartSide?
LP SmartSide is durable but can be more vulnerable to moisture-related issues if not installed or sealed correctly. Because it’s an engineered wood product, long-term performance in high‑humidity or heavy‑rainfall climates may be less reliable than fiber cement. It also has a shorter historical track record compared to Hardie Board, which some homeowners consider when evaluating longevity.
Which siding is easier to install?
LP SmartSide is easier to cut, handle, and install. Its lightweight design speeds up installation and can reduce labor costs. Hardie Board requires special tools and more labor.
Which siding is better for cold climates?
LP SmartSide performs well in cold and dry climates due to its engineered wood core. However, Hardie Board may be a better option in areas with moisture from snow or ice, thanks to its fiber cement composition.
Fresh From our Blog
